Pushpay vs. Tithe.ly Giving
Side-by-side on cost, team fit, integrations, and industry coverage. Ranked on fit, never on commission.
Online, text, and kiosk-based tithing/donation processing with pledge tracking and automated giving statements for tax receipts.
Lower-cost online and mobile giving platform bundling donation processing, texting-to-give, and giving reports, a common alternative to Pushpay for smaller churches.
We may earn a commission when you provision a tool through StackMatch. It can't affect rankings — the recommendation engine is structurally isolated from commission data. Read our methodology.
Spec comparison
| Spec | Pushpay | Tithe.ly Giving |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost | $150/mo | $65/mo |
| Team size fit | 1-100 emp. | 1-60 emp. |
| Category | Giving & donation processing | Giving & donation processing |
| Integrations | 2 | 2 |
| Industries covered | 1 | 1 |
How they differ
Tithe.ly Giving is the lower-cost option at $65/mo versus $150/mo for Pushpay — a $85/mo difference. Tithe.ly Giving appears in more curated industry stacks (1 vs. 1), meaning it fits a broader range of business types. Tithe.ly Giving targets a narrower employee range (1–60) compared to Pushpay (1–100), making Tithe.ly Giving the more focused fit if your headcount is inside that band. Neither tool is universally "better." The right choice depends on whether your priority is lower monthly cost, broader industry fit, deeper integrations, or a headcount-specific match.
See the right fit for your business
Run the free audit with your actual headcount and spend to see which tool our blind engine recommends for your stack.
Run the free audit- Lower cost
- Tithe.ly Giving
- More integrations
- Pushpay
- Wider team-size fit
- Pushpay
Not a ranking — see "How they differ" below for the fit that matters for you.